On 12 November 2026 Aleryc Digital Studio used the free tool axe-core to check the home page of 709 business websites, the same ones as in our October studies on Genoa and Umbria.
93% have at least one serious accessibility error detected automatically (661 out of 709), with the same share in Genoa, in the province of Terni and in the rest of Umbria. Of the 64 websites that sell online, 63 have at least one serious error. An automated check only finds part of the problems and does not say whether a business complies with the law: many small businesses are exempt.
93% of the business websites checked in Genoa and Umbria have at least one serious accessibility error detected automatically with axe-core (661 out of 709 home pages, 12 November 2026; websites taken from OpenStreetMap), according to research by Aleryc Digital Studio.
How to cite this study: Aleryc Digital Studio, “Are business websites in Genoa and Umbria accessible?”, 12 November 2026, https://aleryc.com/research-website-accessibility-genoa-umbria-2026 · Data (CSV, CC BY 4.0): https://aleryc.com/assets/ricerca/accessibility-genoa-umbria-2026-aggregate-data.csv
After our studies on businesses in Genoa and Umbria, we went back to the same websites with a new question: can people who have trouble seeing, use a screen reader or browse only with the keyboard actually use them?
On this page you’ll only find overall figures, always shown with the total they are based on. We don’t publish business names or rankings. Aleryc Digital Studio makes websites: that is why the method and the limits are explained in full at the end.
The numbers at a glance
Nine websites out of ten, everywhere
Out of 709 home pages checked, 661 (93%) have at least one error that the tool classifies as serious. The share is the same in the three areas: 93% in Genoa (210 out of 226), 93% in the province of Terni (97 out of 104), 93% in the rest of Umbria (354 out of 379). Only 48 websites (7%) show no errors in the automated check.
| Area | At least one serious error | No errors detected |
|---|---|---|
| Genoa | 93% (210 out of 226) | 7% (16 out of 226) |
| Province of Terni | 93% (97 out of 104) | 7% (7 out of 104) |
| Rest of Umbria | 93% (354 out of 379) | 7% (25 out of 379) |
| Total | 93% (661 out of 709) | 7% (48 out of 709) |
By type of business the picture doesn’t change: restaurants, bars and cafés 91% (195 out of 214), hotels, farm stays and B&Bs 93% (251 out of 269), shops 95% (206 out of 216).
What it means: this is not a problem of one city or one sector. Those who make and those who commission websites for small businesses, almost everywhere, don’t put accessibility among the things to check. And “no errors detected” doesn’t mean “accessible”: the tool only sees part of the problems.
The most common errors, in plain words
| Error | Websites with the error |
|---|---|
| Text hard to read because of its contrast with the background | 67% (476 out of 709) |
| Links without a name (icons without text for screen readers) | 63% (445 out of 709) |
| Images without alternative text | 30% (214 out of 709) |
| Zoom blocked on phones | 25% (178 out of 709) |
| Embedded maps or videos without a title | 13% (91 out of 709) |
| Form fields without a label | 12% (87 out of 709) |
| Buttons without a name | 9% (64 out of 709) |
| Page language not stated | 8% (58 out of 709) |
Even without counting contrast, 85% of websites have at least one serious error (606 out of 709).
What it means: a screen reader reads the page aloud to people who can’t see. Faced with an Instagram icon without a name, it only says “link”; faced with a photo without a description, it says nothing; if the language is not stated, it may read Italian with the wrong pronunciation. Low contrast, on the other hand, affects everyone: older people, people with low vision and anyone looking at their phone in the sun. These are almost always small fixes.
Online shops
Of the 709 websites, 64 (9%) sell online: they have an e-commerce platform, such as WooCommerce, Shopify or PrestaShop, and a basket already on the home page. There are 20 in Genoa, 12 in the province of Terni and 32 in the rest of Umbria.
Of these, 63 have at least one serious error and only 1 shows no errors in the automated check. Hard-to-read text appears in 51 shops out of 64 and links without a name in 52 out of 64: often they are the basket, search and account icons.
What it means: right where a person has to choose, add to the basket and pay, an icon without a name is an obstacle. There are few online shops, so these figures should be read as indicative. And we only looked at the home page, not the basket or the payment.
What the law says
Since 28 June 2025 the European Accessibility Act (EU Directive 2019/882), transposed by Legislative Decree 82/2022, has applied in Italy. Among other things, it covers e-commerce services aimed at consumers: websites and apps used to buy online. Microenterprises that provide services, meaning those with fewer than 10 people and no more than 2 million euros in turnover or balance sheet total, are exempt.
In 2026 AgID, the supervising authority, published the guidelines on the accessibility of services (March), opened a platform for reports and approved a new regulation on supervision (May). As a technical reference, the guidelines point to the EN 301 549 standard and WCAG 2.1, levels A and AA, the same rules used in this research. For those who are obliged, the penalties range from 5,000 to 40,000 euros; AgID states that it prefers agreed corrections first.
What it means: this research does not say who complies with the law and who doesn’t. Many businesses in the sample are very probably microenterprises, and therefore exempt, and an automated check of the home page alone is not enough to assess compliance. But an accessible website is easier for everyone to use, and businesses that sell online and grow will get there sooner or later.
Sources: Directive (EU) 2019/882 on EUR-Lex; Legislative Decree 82/2022 on Normattiva; AgID guidelines, version 1.0 of 4 March 2026, published on 11 March 2026; AgID regulation on supervision, 29 May 2026. Consulted on 12 November 2026. This information is not legal advice.
How we did it
- Websites: the same ones as in the October 2026 studies, taken from OpenStreetMap (data © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL licence): those whose home page we had read at the time: 232 in Genoa, 106 in the province of Terni and 386 in the rest of Umbria, that is the 740 that worked minus the 16 whose content could not be read. For Genoa and the province of Terni they are all the websites found; for the rest of Umbria, a randomly drawn sample. 724 websites in total, 709 measured.
- Tool: axe-core 4.10.3, free and open source, inside Google Chrome. WCAG 2.0 and 2.1 rules, levels A and AA. An error is “serious” when axe-core gives it a critical or serious impact.
- Rules: a single visit to the home page of each website, on 12 November 2026, at most two at a time. Cookie banners were not closed. We did not save any text or images from the pages. We only publish overall figures.
- Online shops: a website counts as an online shop if the home page code contains a recognised e-commerce platform and a basket or an “add to basket” button.
- The totals: of the 724 websites, 8 responded with an error, 5 could no longer be reached and on 2 the tool could not run. That leaves 709: 226 in Genoa, 104 in the province of Terni, 379 in the rest of Umbria. Each percentage shows its total and is rounded to the nearest whole number.
The limits of this research
- Automated checks only find part of the accessibility problems: according to the maker of axe-core they cover 16 of the 50 WCAG 2.1 AA criteria, about a third, although by number of issues found the share rises above half; in a UK government test the best tool found 41% of the barriers. Our figures are therefore a minimum.
- A website with no errors detected is not necessarily accessible: keyboard, reading order, clarity of the text, forms and payments need to be tested by hand.
- The research does not assess legal compliance: we don’t know which businesses are exempt microenterprises.
- We only looked at the home page, once, on a computer. Maps, booking widgets, chats and cookie banners count: part of the errors may come from them.
- There are 64 online shops and they are recognised with automated rules: some may have been missed. Differences of a few points between the areas should not be read as significant.
What a business can do
- Test your home page for free: in Chrome, right-click, “Inspect”, then the Lighthouse tab and the “Accessibility” item. Alternatively there is WebAIM’s WAVE tool.
- Ask whoever looks after your website for the four most common fixes: more readable text where the contrast is low, a description for the important photos, a name for icons that are links, no blocking of zoom on phones. And the page language stated in the code.
- Press Tab several times on the keyboard: you must be able to reach menus and buttons, and always see where you are.
- If you sell online and are not a microenterprise, check the obligations of Decree 82/2022 with your adviser: they mainly concern basket, login and payment.
We also cover this in our guide Accessible website. Aleryc Digital Studio is a web agency that builds the online presence of local businesses, freelancers and small companies.
How to cite this study
You can reuse the figures by citing the source with a link to this page:
Aleryc Digital Studio, “Are business websites in Genoa and Umbria accessible?”, 12 November 2026, https://aleryc.com/research-website-accessibility-genoa-umbria-2026
The aggregate data can be downloaded as a CSV file: aggregate data of the study (CSV) (data dictionary). It contains no website addresses or business names and is published under the CC BY 4.0 licence. It contains information from OpenStreetMap, under the ODbL licence. For questions about the method: info@aleryc.com.